Remember that photo which stirred all sorts of talk about Amazon’s upcoming God of War TV series? Well, the show won’t look like that anymore—the role of Kratos is set to be recast since actor Ryan Hurst tore a bicep on set, according to Deadline. Anonymous sources in that story claim Hurst has had surgery and is recovering.

As Deadline points out, this comes after Hurst “underwent a physical transformation” and put on 40 pounds of muscle specifically to play Kratos. But for such a physical role and with a rapidly aging child actor (who’s in every scene with the character, one assumes) to consider, it seems starting over is the simplest way forward for Amazon.

Production paused right after the injury and is planned to restart by mid-October with someone new in the role. In other words, any scenes that have already been shot will have to be redone—with four episodes already wrapped, that’s a huge reset. After a mixed reaction to that initial photo, Hurst won’t get the chance to prove his naysayers wrong in the end.

Hurst is also in Christopher Nolan’s new Odyssey movie as Mentor, and theater-avoidant gamers may know him as Thor in God of War: Ragnarok or Beta in AMC’s Walking Dead series. It’s not clear who will take his place, but given the reported production schedule, we won’t be waiting long to find out.

Setbacks aside, at least the show will be easier to experience on your PC than God of War Laufey, which seems likely to forego the PC.